30 Unique & Meaningful Alternative Engagement Ring Ideas

Planning to pop the question? The ring you choose plays a major role in making the moment truly special. After all, it’s something your partner will wear every single day, so it needs to be just right.

While you’ve got plenty to consider - like the perfect time, place, cost, and whether your other half would prefer a quiet moment or something more public - the ring is what they’ll cherish forever. Whether you’re confident about what they’ll love or you’re aiming for a surprise, choosing the right engagement ring is no small task.

While diamonds and classic designs have their place, many couples today opt for something different. Unique styles, alternative gemstones, or even family heirlooms are becoming increasingly popular. Remember, proposals are personal, and what’s perfect for one couple may not be for another. Whether it’s a trendy emerald, an eco-friendly lab-grown stone, or something completely unexpected, the key is finding a ring your partner truly loves.

And if a ring isn’t quite your style, there are plenty of other ways to symbolise your love - from tattoos to planting a tree together. These alternatives can be just as meaningful and lasting.

To help inspire your own proposal, Rock My Wedding chatted with jewellery guru and qualified gemmologist Harriet Haxby from Harriet & Hera to explore the growing trend of alternative engagement rings. Here’s what you need to know.

The 30 Best Alternative Engagement Ring Ideas for All Kinds of Couples, Plus 6 Alternatives to Shop

Our editors independently research, review, and recommend the best products. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

10 Alternative Engagement Ring Ideas

1. Birthstone Ring

Choose a ring that features your partner's birthstone or a combination of both of your birthstones for a meaningful choice. Birthstones make a great alternative to some of the classic gemstones used for popular engagement rings, and brownie points for a personal touch, too! 

2. Lab-Grown Stones
 

Opt for lab-grown diamonds or gemstones, which are not only environmentally friendly but also more budget-conscious without compromising on beauty. Qualified gemmologist, Harriet Haxby tells us that "lab diamonds are chemically, physically and optically identical to mined diamonds", but still encourages all clients to do their own research, too! What’s not to love? 

3. Family Heirloom

A ring passed down through generations offers a sentimental touch, making it a timeless alternative to a traditional engagement ring. The perfect way to incorporate a much-loved family member into your special day!

4. Handmade Ring

Support artisans by choosing a handmade ring, either from a local craftsperson or an online platform like Etsy. The best thing about handmade rings is that each piece is unique, adding to its specialness.

5. Simple Band

A sleek and elegant precious metal band can serve as a minimalist yet meaningful engagement ring, offering timeless simplicity. Because, sometimes, less is more!

6. Vintage Ring

Scour vintage stores or charity shops for a one-of-a-kind piece that carries a story of its own. A vintage ring is full of character and charm, making it the perfect alternative to a new and shiny engagement ring. Better yet, ring expert, Harriet Haxby, predicts an increase in interest surrounding vintage and antique rings, suggesting that actually, vintage rings are the most truly sustainable option for an engagement ring. 

7. Eternity Ring

Traditionally given after a significant milestone, an eternity ring can be a beautiful symbol of everlasting love, breaking the tradition by giving it as an engagement ring. Who said traditions aren’t to be broken?

8. Wooden Ring

For a rustic and eco-friendly option, consider a wooden ring. It’s a unique choice that stands out from traditional metals and stones.

9. Cluster Ring

Instead of a single stone, a cluster ring features multiple smaller stones arranged in an intricate design, creating a distinctive and dazzling effect.

10. Engraved Band

Add a personal touch with an engraved message or initials inside the band, making the ring uniquely yours and full of sentimental value.

 

10 Jewellery Pieces That Can Serve as Alternative Engagement Rings

11. Necklace

A necklace, especially one with a meaningful pendant, can be a beautiful alternative to an engagement ring. It rests close to the heart, and something like a locket can hold a small photo or a secret message for an extra layer of sentimentality.

12. Bracelet

A bracelet is a piece of jewellery that's often worn daily, making it a constant reminder of your commitment. Choose a design that resonates with your partner’s style, whether it’s a delicate chain or a statement piece.

13. Charm Bracelet

Charm bracelets are highly personal and can evolve over time. Start with a few significant charms that represent your relationship, and add more as your journey together continues. This allows the bracelet to grow as a living story of your love - the perfect heirloom in the making.

14. Brooch

For those who appreciate vintage styles, a brooch can be an elegant alternative. Often seen as a statement piece, a brooch can carry deep meaning, especially if it’s a family heirloom or features a design significant to your relationship.

15. Earrings

A pair of special earrings, perhaps featuring birthstones, diamonds, or a design meaningful to your relationship, can be a beautiful symbol of your engagement. Earrings are versatile and can be worn daily or on special occasions.

16. Watch

A luxury watch, especially one engraved with a personal message, is both practical and symbolic. It’s a constant reminder of the time you’ve spent together and the future you’re planning. Plus, a watch can be a significant and stylish investment piece.

17. Welded Jewellery

Welded bracelets or necklaces are literally welded onto your wrist or neck, creating a seamless piece of jewellery you never have to take off. This modern, minimalist option is all about long-lasting commitment, making it the perfect engagement ring alternative. It’s a subtle yet incredibly meaningful option for couples who want something unique. 

18. Cufflinks

Cufflinks are perfect for those who appreciate sophisticated accessories. Engraved with initials, a date, or a special message, they serve as a stylish and personal symbol of your engagement, often worn on formal occasions.

19. Body Jewellery

For the more adventurous, body jewellery like a belly button ring, nose stud, or even a septum ring can be a bold and meaningful alternative. This choice is perfect for those who want something unconventional.

20. Signet Ring

Unlike a traditional engagement ring, a signet ring can be engraved with initials, a meaningful symbol, or a family crest. It’s a timeless piece often passed down through generations, making it a personal alternative.
 

10 Alternative Engagement Ring Ideas That Aren’t Jewellery

21. Tattoos

If body art is something you both love, getting matching or complementary tattoos can be the perfect way to symbolise your engagement. Unlike a traditional ring, a tattoo is permanent, representing the lifelong commitment you’re making to each other.

22. Handfasting Ceremony

Traditionally part of a wedding, handfasting can be a beautiful and symbolic gesture during your engagement. By tying your hands together with a ribbon, you physically and metaphorically bind your lives, marking the beginning of your journey together.

23. Handwritten Letter or Journal of Love

There’s something deeply intimate about putting pen to paper. Whether it’s a single heartfelt letter or a journal filled with entries that trace your relationship’s milestones, presenting this during your proposal creates a lasting keepsake that your partner can cherish forever. A handwritten letter or journal serves as a beautiful reminder of your journey together and the promises you’ve made for the future.

24. Wedding Fund Contribution

Instead of spending money on an engagement ring, consider starting your wedding fund. This practical gesture symbolises your shared commitment to the future and can help you save for the day when you’ll officially become partners for life. Alternatively, you could donate the equivalent amount to a charity close to your partner’s heart.

25. Custom Artwork

Commissioning a piece of artwork - whether it’s a painting, drawing, or piece of digital art - can be a unique and lasting symbol of your love. Choose an artist you both admire or create the artwork yourself, making it a personal and creative alternative to a traditional ring.

26. Plant a Tree Together

Planting a tree together is a beautiful metaphor for the growth and nurturing of your relationship. Watching the tree flourish over the years will serve as a constant reminder of the life you’re building together, and it’s a gesture that gives back to the environment as well.

27. Keepsake Box

A keepsake box is a meaningful alternative to an engagement ring. You can fill it with memories from your relationship, such as photos, or mementoes from special moments. It’s the perfect way to preserve your shared history and look forward to creating more memories together.

28. Proposal Video

Create a heartfelt video montage of your favourite moments together, culminating in the proposal. Video can be a sentimental way to relive your journey as a couple and share it with friends and family. It’s a keepsake that can be watched for years to come.

29. Celebrity Video Message

For a fun twist to a conventional proposal, consider getting a personalised video message from your partner’s favourite celebrity through services like Cameo. It’s a unique way to involve someone they admire in your proposal (even if it is from their younger fangirl days), making the moment even more special and memorable.

30. Star Naming

Name a star after your partner or your relationship through a star-naming registry. Present them with the certificate and a map showing the star’s location in the sky. It’s a romantic and symbolic gesture that will last forever. 
 

Choosing the Perfect Alternative Engagement Ring for Your Special Moment

Choosing an alternative to a traditional engagement ring can make your proposal even more meaningful and personal. Whether it’s a handwritten letter, a symbolic tattoo, or planting a tree together, these unique gestures reflect the individuality of your relationship. Remember, it’s not about following tradition but creating a moment that you’ll remember forever! 

For even more inspo for the non-traditional bride, check out our favourite alternative wedding dresses.